This Cult Pore Clay Mask Now Comes in a Sensitive Skin Version & Here’s Our Verdict

innisfree clay mask review innisfree clay mask review

Anyone else's skin been looking and feeling a little worse for wear lately?

Maybe it's lockdown. Or the pandemic. Or some stressful life stuff combined with the usual winter skin culprits like dry winds, boiling hot showers and blasting the heater all day. Or all of the above.

Regardless of the 'why', my skin's been needing some extra attention. So when an email from my editor asking me to review a new clay mask appeared in my inbox, it felt like divine intervention.

The mask in question? innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Pore Mask 100ml

If the name sounds familiar, that's because it's a new, gentler version of the best-selling innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask.

No joke, over 10 million pots of the pore mask have sold globally in the last decade.

innisfree clay mask review innisfree clay mask review

If you have oily or combination skin, you’re probably familiar with clay masks.

That’s because their main jobs are to draw out impurities, absorb excess oils from the skin, and reduce the appearance of blackheads and enlarged pores. 

But if you have dry or sensitive skin, traditional clay masks can leave the skin feeling tight, stripped and drier than before.

innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Mask is made with sensitive and dry skin folk in mind, but how does it compare to the original cult innisfree clay mask?

I put both to the test to find out, so keep scrolling for my innisfree clay mask reviews.

Which innisfree Clay Mask is Best?

Clay masks have been around for thousands of years… Even Cleopatra applied mud masks made from the Dead Sea to maintain a lovely complexion. 

The new and original innisfree clay masks both contain mud with volcanic clusters rich in minerals from Jeju Island in South Korea. They're also formulated with kaolin clay, known for its oil and sebum absorbing powers.

That said, these two clay masks have different formulations to cater to different skin types and skin concerns.

Here's a recap of the main differences between the original innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask (pictured right) and the new innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Pore Mask (pictured left).

innisfree clay mask review innisfree clay mask review

1. innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Pore Mask, $30 for 100ml.

innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Pore Mask 100ml promises to be just as effective as the original Super Volcanic Clay Mask, but in a gentler, less-irritating way for drier and sensitised skin types.

Think of it as melting away dead skin cells and gunk for a smoother, brighter-looking complexion.

Main ingredients:

  • Volcanic Sphere Plus™, a newer and more effective complex based off the original innisfree Jeju volcanic clusters.

  • AHAs (alpha hydroxy acids) glycolic and lactic acid, and PHAs (polyhydroxy acids) exfoliate the surface layers of skin.

  • Madecassoside, a plant-based antioxidant ingredient with anti-inflammatory properties that hydrates and revitalises skin.

  • Carbonated Spring Water from Jeju Island soothes skin.

The creamy, lighter consistency is gentle enough for everyday use, and suitable for all skin types, including blemish-prone and sensitised skin.

Bonus: It's super quick!

You only need to leave it on for five minutes, as opposed to 20-30 minutes.

Shop innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Pore Mask here:

2. innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask, $22 for 100ml.

The original innisfree clay mask formula is a cult Korean skincare product loved for its ability to absorb excess oil and refine the look of enlarged pores.

innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask comes in a clay mask tub with a thicker more 'clay-like' texture, and you leave it on for 15-20 minutes.

Think of this mask as a deep clean, for your pores. It'll get right in there and clear everything out - excellent for congested areas of the face like the nose, chin, jawline and forehead. Or all over if you have oiler skin.

Main ingredients: Triple exfoliation with Volcanic Clusters, walnut shells, and AHAs glycolic and lactic acids.

This product is best suited to normal to combination and oily skin types, or for use to address congestion.

Shop innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask here:

My innisfree Clay Pore Mask Reviews.

OK cool, but how do these masks compare in the way they feel on the skin and the results they deliver?

I road-tested both, and here's what I found.

1. innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Pore Mask Review.

innisfree clay mask review innisfree clay mask review

The results of this mask are subtle, but you can see my dull complexion was lifted to reveal clearer and slightly brighter-looking skin.

Basically, my skin looked like I'd taken a nice, long nap!

My skin also felt a little softer, which made my moisturiser apply smoother. 

Here's a quick before and after shot.

innisfree clay mask review innisfree clay mask review

A few other notes:

  • Creamy texture glides on like a dream and washes off really easily.

  • Tube packaging and texture means it's not messy to use.

  • The mask dries quite quickly but it doesn't dry down fully, so no aggressive cracking or stripping feeling like you get with some clay masks.

  • I left it on for seven minutes, and didn’t experience any tingling. Plus, my skin didn’t feel stripped afterwards.

  • I was also expecting an earthy smell, but it hardly has a scent at all.

You can watch this little video below for a closer look at the innisfree calming clay mask in action!

Shop innisfree Volcanic Calming Clay Pore Mask here:

2. innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask Review.

innisfree clay mask review innisfree clay mask review

The brand’s Instagram says the Super Volcanic Pore Mask “helps clear pores, even skin tone and cleanse pollution particles."

The sebum around my nose was very interested in this. 

Results-wise, my complexion looked a little more refined overall after use, like it’d had a really good clean. Next time, I'd use it straight after a steamy shower for even deeper results.

I look forward to seeing the results on my pores and the sebum around my nose in a few weeks with consistent use. 

innisfree clay mask review innisfree clay mask review

A few other notes:

  • I was worried the heavier clay mask texture would irritate my skin, but the texture stayed mostly creamy and didn't crack at all.

  • After five minutes, I experienced a very mild tingle, but then it felt weirdly cooling on the skin... in a good way!

  • The texture didn't make my skin feel super tight, but I think the key is only leaving the mask on for as long as feels good for your skin.

  • This mask took longer to wash off - you could use a face washer or a reusable cleansing wipe to remove leftover residue.

Shop innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask here:

Final Verdict...

Which innisfree clay mask is the best for you depends on your skin type and the skin concerns you want to target.

Got oilier or congestion-prone skin and want a deeper, purifying clean? Go for the Super Volcanic Clay Mask. I’m going to use this one mostly on my nose and chin.

Have dry skin or skin on the sensitive side, but still want a gentle yet effective exfoliating mask? The Volcanic Calming is for you.

Now, all you have to do is decide which one's right for you and add it to cart!

Shop innisfree clay masks here:

    Subscribe for beauty sales, free goodies, advice and SO much more!