1. Home
  2. Brand
  3. Benefit Cosmetics
  4. Brows
  5. Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

4.6 of 358 reviews


4 instalments of $11.25

Or 4 instalments of $11.25 with LEARN MORE

In Stock 

4 instalments of $11.25

Or 4 instalments of $11.25 with LEARN MORE

Official Stockist

Is this for you?

Oh my WOW…precise & defined brows! Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil is the ultimate brow defining pencil. The ultra-fine tip draws incredibly natural-looking hair-like strokes while the textured, custom-control grip gives extra control.

What customers say

SUPERIOR - 94% recommend

Read all reviews

Frequently bought with

Please wait while we find a match

Questions & Answers

(1 Question)

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Get an expert to answer your question about this product!

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil Reviews

4.6 of 358 reviews

94% recommend this product

  1. 240

  2. 97

  3. 19

  4. 3

  5. 0

Most Helpful Positive

Best of the Best


Benefit always delivers with brow & lash products. This pencil is fine & delivers a super tidy look that look like real hair strokes. Great for defining the top line of the brow too

Most Helpful Criticism

Good but Ridiculously Overpriced


Great range of shades and a fine tip that's good for drawing on individual hairs, however definitely not even close to being worth the price. I went through this super fast and decided to get a drugstore alternative instead of repurchasing and am just as happy.
  1. Good but Ridiculously Overpriced


    Great range of shades and a fine tip that's good for drawing on individual hairs, however definitely not even close to being worth the price. I went through this super fast and decided to get a drugstore alternative instead of repurchasing and am just as happy.
  2. Best of the Best


    Benefit always delivers with brow & lash products. This pencil is fine & delivers a super tidy look that look like real hair strokes. Great for defining the top line of the brow too
  3. love it


    fantastic brow pencil. Really thin so the lines can be precise but i've never had one snap on me. I've had two of these pencils now, and both have been excellent. i love a natural yet defined brow and this gives me the results with minimal effort.
  4. Favourite brow pencil


    I used benefits goof proof for years but bought this by accident from the benefit store. Tried it and loved it. It’s so nice and feel lighter compared to goof proof. And the colour is great and long lasting. The pencil nib is a bit thin, so be gentle so it doesn’t snap. But definitely repurchasing
  5. Great application


    The shape of the tip allows me to get a more precise application, and the brush on the opposite end allows me to diffuse the colour so it looks more natural. I do try to be careful with it though since the pencil is quite thin and feels a bit delicate.
  6. My go to brow product


    The pencil is super thin which makes it easy to apply.
    The product is really easy to work with and leaves your eyebrows looking natural.
    The product does use up pretty quickly for the price so I always buy a couple at a time.
  7. Pretty good


    I was exploring alternatives to the usual shu uemura hard formula. This was pretty good - easy to control and there's a good range of colour options.
    Still prefer the shu uemura one, as it seems to last longer and I personally find that it looks more natural, but this one was pretty good!
  8. Awesome


    This is a fantastic pencil. Effective, super natural and easy to use.
    I use it with the benefit brow gel.
  9. Love


    This product is lovely! Easy to use with precise application. I love how thin the tip is which means precise lines every time, however its so thin that you only get minimal product and it a little expensive for the price. Would still probably repurchase though because of all the great brow days ive been having!
  10. Good but snaps A LOT


    I loved this brow pencil/crayon. The thinness is great for making small strokes in the brow and makes them super natural looking. It's a good texture etc BUT it snaps ALL THE TIME! It got to the point where it was snapping every time I used it. I feel like you only get to use half of the product by the time you get to the bottom.
  11. Very precise as named


    This pencil is goof proof as it has an ultra fine tip that you use to gradually build your brow
    colour up. Only thing is I have a different brow product that I prefer the colour of. If I was
    not using that this pencil would be my next option
  12. best eye brow pencil


    The best eye brow pencil I found so far. A little bit expensive but have not found an alternative yet


    Love it, this product is absolutely perfect if you have fine, thinner brows :)
  14. favourite eyebrow pencil


    I'm really blonde and I finally found a food colour for my eyebrows, love this!
  15. Brow beauty


    Fills in your brow gaps! Perfect size too.
  16. Great brow product!


    Makes my eyebrows look AMAZING!
  17. Best brow product I have tried


    This is the most natural brown product I have tried. Fills in the gaps and a good range of shades to choose from.
  18. The best!


    Lives up to its expectation! Beautiful texture, smooth, great colour. Don't need to apply much pressure. Love!
  19. Amazing!!


    So simple, but makes such a difference :)
  20. Natural


    Perfect for a discreet and delicate makeup brows. It makes fine lines, is not greasy and doesn’t pill. The eyebrow remains natural. On the other hand, be careful not to break the pencil mine, it is so fine that it is fragile... it would be a shame...given the price
  21. great eye brow pencil


    this is a great eyebrow pencil it is the perfect amount of smooth and blendable and gives and exact line, very impressed and would buy again
  22. My favourite


    I have tried other brow pencils but this is my favourite by far. I have ombre brows from having them microbladed.
    This helps to deepen and give a full affect to my brows.
    I love this product so much. I have just ordered another.
    Great with a spooli on the end and finish with eyebrow gel and it looks great.Love it!!!
  23. Works wonders


    I use this pencil every day and it's pretty good, however it annoys me so much waste of plastic! Every one of these have a brush but when I buy the one without the brush comes like 50% less pencil.... Why? I just want the same amount of pencil but I have so many brushes that is not necessary!
    The price is a bit too much as well, it could be less without having the brush.
  24. The best brow product


    I’ve been buying this pencil for about 5 years. Previously I used a powder but moved away from that cause it was easy to overdo it and have a bad brow day with obviously filled in brows. This product just gets such a natural finish. I think sometimes people don’t know I even have product in - sometimes people compliment me on my ‘natural brows’ but it’s all cause of this pencil that somehow just l...
    Read More
  25. shade 6


    shade 6 is the perfect cool toned black brown shade for those with black hair. so many brands have really warm toned pencils but this is such a perfect shade. the tip is super precise for creating hair like strokes
  26. Amazing


    Natural looking, doesn't smudge, lasts all day even through sweaty brow days. I love the packaging too.
  27. Love this


    Love this brow pencil, lasts so long as well so well worth the money. Easy to use and the brush end blends in the pencil well. I have dark brown hair And like my brows fairly dark. I use the number 4 shade.
  28. you'll never use anything else


    So easy to use and gives a natural look to eyebrows. I never buy anything else now and the colour range means you'll find your perfect match. Doesn't smudge, stays put all day
  29. best brow pencil


    this is my holy grail brow pencil. it's so easy to shape your brows and still have it look natural because of the super fine and precise tip
  30. The perfect brow pencil!!!!!


    I love this thing - I have really thin brows and it lets my fill them in as much as I want without looking freakily fake. You can pencil your brows in really precisely or feather it and blur (with the spoolie) so that you get a more natural look. Definitely give it a go!! :))
  31. Great for the lazy and time-poor


    As I've said in some of my other reviews, I don't often wear makeup at all as my work hours and long and I really don't care!. My go-to look is Clarins Flash Beauty balm, brows, mascara and some tinted lip balm (Bobbi Brown). This is my favourite brow pencil as, despite not having a spoolie or brush for a quick sculpt, it has good staying power and blends well. I simply use a cheap old brow brush,...
    Read More
  32. Great eyebrow pencil

    Cindy C

    This is a great eyebrow pencil, love the shape of the pencil and the colour pay off. Makes it super easy for me to do my brows in the morning. The colour holds pretty well throughout the day, even with my oily skin. Took 1 star off because of the price!
  33. Took time to like


    At first use it had a grey film over the pencil. It was only once I warmed it up and rubbed it on the back of my hand for a while that the film wore away and the pigment came through. I was scared to brake it while trying to wear away the film. After that it was good to go.
  34. naturally bulks up your brown


    makes fine hairs look thick and can be used to give an amazing shape
  35. Neat and precise


    This is a great eyebrow pencil as it applies well and is well suited to my shade however i have found that the stick is slightly fragile.
  36. Best eyebrow pencil


    I've been on a quest for the best eyebrow products over the last year and I keep coming back to this brow pencil paired with the Gimme Brow. The product is really easy to use, as it has a smooth consistency. The only issue I had is that it seemed to run out quite fast but at this price, I'm happy to buy it again when it runs out.
  37. amazing


    I brought the small or travel-sized first then this one. I had seen so many reviews and beauty gurus use it. so I brought as well and I've got to say it one of the best products out there I've tried other ones but this is the one I always come back to.
  38. Great but delicate


    Love the colour but it can snap if you apply too much pressure
  39. benefit


    amazing for creating those natural brows with super fine and precise strokes. Love this! The brow pencil is so fine and easy to create nice strokes with
  40. Enjoyed


    I really loved the small tip on this brow pencil, it make it very easy to draw realistic brow hairs where I wanted them to be filled in. My only complaint would be the pencil drying out after a while, but I did own my pencil for a few years so that might just be me.
  41. So nice


    The fine point is precise and natural-looking, I find the formula smooth but not too soft, and it does not smudge during the day! The spoolie is good quality too
  42. Works but worth the price?


    The Benefit brow pencil works well in shaping and defining your eyebrows and I got it after visiting a benefit store for a brow wax session.

    The only thing I would say is the pencil works like any other brow pencil and I think the brush attachment is why there is so much hype around the product.

    Lasts me a while but unsure if I will repurchase for the price.
  43. Decent


    This is a great general eyebrow pencil i just think that there may be some better alternatives in both the lower and same price ranges.

    Allows you to draw very natural looking, thin strokes.

    Comes with a spoolie which is really handy.
  44. the best


    This is the best eyebrow pencil in the market for me. The color is so ashy and pretty. I love it. I will buy again and again. Looks very natural
  45. Nothing special


    I don't really like this product, and the spoolie doesn't brush that well through the brows as well. The product is too soft and easily transfers so what's the point of drawing "hair-like strokes" if the definition just gets rubbed easily? Needs to be a bit firmer and more long wearing, this does not create natural looking brows
  46. Great, but not worth the price!


    I really like this brow pencil, however I've found much cheaper alternatives that do the same job!
  47. Disapointed for the money


    I have tried a few pencils and was hoping this would be the one BUT i have a eye brow pencil I bought 3 for $10 on special at Chemist Warehouse that honestly gives the same affect, I wouldn't buy this one again, I don't see that it has any huge benefit over others.
  48. My favourie brow pencil


    I love this fine brow pencil to define my brows without ever going over the top. I have tried the travel size but I like the full size most as it comes with a spoolie to brush through your brows. This pencil is the perfect width to create hair like strokes for a natural look. The texture is the perfect mix of pencil and wax to be natural looking but stay put all day. I like to set it with the Bene...
    Read More
  49. Convenient


    I have naturally full and thick dark brows that I like to feather and keep natural. This helps me fill the sparse bits quickly and flawlessly. Not sure if the tip would be precise or fine enough to feather very fine eyebrows but would easily create a sculpted, bold brow.
  50. Favourite brow product


    I was introduced to this brow pencil when I got my brows waxed at the Benefit counter in Myer. At this point, I've gone through at least 3 of these and would highly recommend it. My mum converted to this brow pencil as well after she experiences how easy it is to use. What's great about this is how natural your brows look once you've brushed it through.
  51. nice small tip


    I do like it and so many colour options but not sure its worth the price tag, when AB brow wiz is cheaper.
  52. Allows you to draw precise strokes

    Bridget L

    This is the best eyebrow pencil I've used for precision. My eyebrows only really grow to the arch and I have to almost completely draw on the tails. With some setting agent on top it stays put all day.
  53. My all time favourite!


    So beautifully pigmented with such a fine tip for easy and precise application. Perfect for that fluffy brow look. My all time favourite brow pencil!
  54. Love it


    I don't think I have met a brow product better than this. It is super easy to use, looks natural and it is smudge proof. Benefit cosmetics does the best brow and lashes product in my opinion.
  55. Brow staple


    I've been using this for years - after initially using ABH. Stays on well and always a fine point allowing me to mimic natural hairstrokes
  56. Subtle and effective


    I am impressed by the colour of this pencil - I have light eyebrows and it's hard to find a match. It glides on easily and the brush is very handy. High price point but definitely one of the best I've come across.
  57. Favourite brow pencil


    This pencil is very thin so you can easily create microblade style lines with it. Creates a really natural brow look.
  58. Amazing brow pencil


    Love this brow pencil and the fact that they have a big range of shades with some warm or neutral colour options. I prefer a neutral colour as I have dark brown hair that is relatively neutral. Don't think a very warm brown is particularly flattering on most people, but each to their own! I use shade 4.5 and it suits me perfectly! It's very easy to use, perfect balance between soft and waxy and re...
    Read More
  59. very natural


    give you very natural looking brows, but not good if you want a more structured powder brow
  60. Good product


    A bit expensive for the product - although it works really well with blending your eyebrows and drawing on eyebrows. It lasts a while as well - on oily skin too.
  61. Favourite brow pencil


    This is my favourite brow pencil. it lasts so long on the brows and looks absolutely gorgeous. I love the extended shade range. It is expensive but well worth the price!
  62. Great brows!


    This is my second purchase of this brow pencil. The tip is Fine and the soft. The colour transfers nicely, and long lasting.
  63. Natural & Bold


    I loveeeeee this brow product, I can create a natural brow and/ or a bold brow depending on the pressure I use when applying it. Defs recommend. I use shade 4 medium and have black hair.
  64. Best brow product


    This product is the best brow product. It saves me from carrying a spoolie and I can draw natural looking hair strokes with it. Highly recommend.
  65. Best Brow Pencil


    I absolutely love this eyebrow pencil the shade is perfect, the look it gives is amazing and it actually lasts longer than expected. Couldn’t recommend more.
  66. The best eyebrow pencil


    I have been purchasing this product for years, by far the best on the market. Easy to achieve natural looking brows and good lasting power. Always complimented on my eyebrows and my secret is this!
  67. Great product


    Applys so smoothly
  68. Good!


    Good alternative to the one i normally use (ABH) but not as thin lined
  69. Natural brows


    This product is good for creating natural looking brows. I personally prefer the look of powder in my brows so I don't reach for this as often. In my opinion it also takes way longer to fill in my brows with this than it would if I were using a powder, so that's why I don't rate it as highly. It is really nice though if you're someone who enjoys a pencil and has more patience than me!
  70. Daily use for perfect brows


    I found this retractable brown pencil perfect for every day use. Didn’t look too OTT and the fact that I don’t have to sharpen it to keep the tip fine enough to fill in my brow gaps (thanks 90s!) is such a win. Recommend!
  71. Best brow pencil there is.


    Definitely the best brow pencil there is in my opinion. Not too hard or too crumbly, and it has the perfect amount of pigment.
  72. NIce and precise


    I like this product a lot, because it doesn't chunk on a heavy line, it really helps sculpt your brow
  73. precisely


    brow hairs look soft and fluffy and natural with this brow product. love how it looks.
  74. it is good


    precisely for sure. easy for using , no matter you are a master or the first learn, you need it !!!
  75. My favourite brow product

    Lisa c

    I’ve repurchased this so many times! It’s got such a precise tip and glides on so easily when outlining my brows.
    The only downside is that it runs out a bit too fast.
  76. Perfect brows!


    The precisely my brow honestly gives you the most perfect brows. The small tip allows you to be extremely precise and make your brows look feathery. I also love that benefit extended their shade range so that there is a shade for everyone
  77. Great product


    Really amazing and keeps my brows looking really fresh and on fleek. Loving it!
  78. Natural looking brows


    The Benefit brow pencil makes your eyebrows look so natural and gives them shape, especially for blondes. It is easy to apply and you can build on the colour of your brows. Different tones to match with your skin/hair colour. Awesome brow product.
  79. very pigmented


    These brow pencils are easy to use and are very soft, but i find the shades too warm and wish there were more cool shades.
  80. Lasts


    I actually find it easier to use pomade to get my brows done fast but if I have the time and want them to last I use this as it has better staying power
  81. perfect

    Chele Pagno

    The shade 03 matches perfectly with my eyebrows - one of the first ever perfect match I have found. The pencil is so precise and easy to manipulate, you can get your brows done quickly or take your time to perfect them.
  82. Best eyebrow pencil


    Absolutely love this brow crayon like pencil, nice and easy to use and produces the strokes I need to fill in brows. I’ve had microblading in the past but haven’t gone back but this is doing the job just fine!
  83. Love love love

    Happy customer

    I expected thin strokes that weren’t noticeable but this is so much better! The benefit brow team at myer helped me decide what colour and since then, I’ve never stopped buying it!
  84. Not too heavy


    The fine point makes it so easy to use and with so many colour options, I found a perfect colour match which looks natural. I will be repurchasing.
  85. Easy to apply


    I use a few brow products together from Benefit on my brows. I have very thin brows due to all the plucking we did in the 90s! This helps shape and define and add to my brows and stays put all day. I highly recommend!
  86. Really good


    It is a good product, stays on all day and is smudge proof.
  87. Pigmented and thin


    Pigmented and draws thin! Works just as well as the ABH Brow Wiz!
  88. Pretty Good Brow Pencil


    I have super fine brows with sparse patchy hair growth. The Benefit suite of brow products work really well for me as I do not end up with that heavy/clearly fake thick 'Scouse' brows look.
  89. Easy and Effective


    I have quite dark brows and use this to fill in a few uneven spaces. It is quick, easy and effective.
  90. perfect


    perfect for create more dramatic brows or just natural brows. Pencil is smooth and pencil colour is pigmented nicely
  91. VERY good eyebrow pencil


    This is one of my favourite eyebrow pencils. I love the formula and I love the amazing colour range they offer in the precisely my brow. The shape of the pencil is amazing and allows for a precise application of the eyebrow. I find you can do very fine strokes, leaving the brow looking natural. I LOVE it, however it can be quite pricey as a pencil and with everyday use you will go through the penc...
    Read More
  92. Precision on offer


    I have quite thick brows and can normally get away with brow gels when I am on the go. But for occasions where i do a full make up, this is definitely my go to brow pencil. The precision you can achieve using this brow pencil is incredible.
  93. Precision on offer


    I have quite thick brows and can normally get away with brow gels when I am on the go. But for occasions where i do a full make up, this is definitely my go to brow pencil. The precision you can achieve using this brow pencil is incredible.
  94. Great brows everytime!


    This is my all time favourite eyebrow product. The fine tip makes it very easy to apply. You can do a more natural fill in or go a bit darker if you want. You may need to go in-store though to pick the right colour - there are so many shade variations. Only thing I don't like about this is that I use it very fast - so it does make for an expensive everyday item.
  95. Good


    Glides on nice and natural colour
  96. Okay product


    Easy to use and good colour match but it's a generic brow pencil that is overpriced. There are brow pencils from affordable brands which give similar results.
  97. Brow pencil


    this brow pencil is really great! thin tip to fill in brows! great color selection! nothing better than benefit brows!
  98. Love this stuff


    I make very fine hair strokes to have more of a natural look. This penicl is very easy to use and there so many colours, so you gonna find the matches for you brow hairs well.
  99. Illusion of full brows


    Great to use with the Gimme Brows brush to add the illusion of full brows when you've got gaps. Very precise as it says and so simple to use!
  100. Holy grail pencil


    One of the best! I love this as I’m able to make very fine hair strokes to have more of a natural look. Very easy to use and colour matches my brow hairs well. I usually alternate between this and the Anastasia Brow Wiz though I might prefer this a little more.
  101. Review & Earn
Recommended for you

Find more of...

Related Searches

Join Now >
Filled with the usual things we know you'll love, and surprises you might not expect, it's real rewards, really simple.