Definitely a MISS!
I purchased the 'clear' version of this, and did not find it exfoliating. It was nourishing, however that is unfortunately not why I purchased the product. If you are looking for a great lip exfoliator to remove dry skin, I would give this product a miss. If you are looking for a very very very gentle exfoliator that is more nourishing than abrasive, this may be suitable for you.