Benefit Roller Lash Mascara 8.5g

I love mascara. And I have spent the last 10 years searching for the one mascara to rule them all. Never have I gone back to a mascara - high end or pharmacy brand. Until now...

I find that because of my oily skin, even waterproof mascara runs and dislodges during the day. And, I have such straight eyelashes that just will not hold a curl. I bought a trial size of the Roller Lash and I AM NEVER LOOKING BACK.

I work/travel long hours, and from the moment I swipe it on til the moment I take it off, my lashes look long, curled, separated, lifted, and pristine. I even went to the gym during my lunch break and I came back to work without having to fix it up.

My life will never be the same. I am in love.

I LOVED They're Real Mascara but this is my new favourite after I gave up having lash extensions. It curls and separates my lashes, and easily coats every single last one without clumping and looks great all day. The smaller size is excellent for keeping in your purse.

No need for an eyelash curler anymore, minimal clumps, super long and curled eyelashes. The brush is amazing too. Has far exceeded my expectations. Definitely recommend, have never found a mascara like it!

I wanted to like this so much. I was recommended this by one of the Adore Beauty staff when I asked for a smudgeproof mascara that would hold up against my oily lids. I like the packaging and I love the way it makes my lashes look. It gives fantastic length and curl. Unfortunately, it also gives me massive panda eyes after a couple of hours. I keep trying it in the hope that I can make it work, and it just keeps smudging. For $40, I would have expected a little more longevity than your average drugstore mascara, and this does not deliver. A total waste of money for me I'm afraid.

I'm a big fan of They're Real mascara. So much so, that I never thought I'd EVER love another mascara as much as I love They're Real. It was perfection in a silver bottle to me.

However, I've now betrayed my one true love. I love these mascaras both equally, but for different reasons.

RollerLash gives me amazing length (I look like I'm wearing falsies!) and ridiculous curl. They're Real gives me the fullness and ultra dark sultry eyelashes of my dreams. When I layer them, it's DIVINE.

If you're a big time They're Real fan, I'd definitely suggest giving this a go. It's a fantastic edition to the Benefit mascara team.

I just received this as a tester in my latest order and I have to say that I am so impressed! My lashes actually look so much longer, defined and wispy. I would almost have to say that this is the best mascara I have ever used and I have used HEAPS! They're real was good but roller lash is just WOW!! Will definitely be purchasing the full size.

I was so excited to try this mascara - read all the reviews and was really keen for it to arrive for me to try it out..... Well I wasn't impressed at all! I feel that they're real mascara is way better - provides length, curl and thickness. With this one I couldn't even get my lashes to go as long or as thick - it had a little bit of a curl but nothing that I was expecting after all of the reviews! I wish I stuck with my ole fav! Won't be repurchasing.

I know a lot of people feel this way, but when the hype around They're Real! convinced me to give it a go, I was pretty underwhelmed. So consider this review somewhat of a comparison of They're Real vs. Rollerlash!

First off though - honestly there's nothing wrong with They're Real, just that my lashes are somewhat short, straight, and I prefer them to look really defined, curled and fluttery.

Rollerlash is really easy to apply, and it's also really easy to apply to your lower lashes as well (I normally use 2 separate mascaras when I want to do both lower and upper!). The wear is really, really long, and it seems to be much easier to remove than They're Real.

If you're using They're Real but want something more soft and fluttery for effortless-looking makeup, this is the way to go!

I like the way my lashes look using this, if you concentrate the mascara on the outer lashes you get a really pretty cat-eye effect (it looks like you aren't even trying, AND it's so easy!)

Benefit is known for their mascaras for a reason! This helps me achieve the look I really love. I would disagree that you don't need a lash curler using this mascara - nothing can really replace a good curler.

Pros:
- Fluttery, lengthened, volumised lashes
- Doesn't clump
- for a Benefit mascara, really easy to remove
- lasts ages

Cons:
- you still need a curler! But you knew that nothing could replace that
- if you want lots of drama, I'd still recommend They're Real over this :)

Love the lift and length this mascara gave me and it wasn't heavy on my lashes

Great for lengthing and really separating the lashes. Gives a great effect.

This mascara was exactly what I was after - lengthens and defines beautifully, leaving a natural look, and not so much thickening and volumising. It also feels lightweight. This is now my go-to mascara <3

Other than a tinted moisturiser and lip-balm I am not a makeup wearer. I purchased the Benefit Roller Lash Mascara mini on the recommendation of my teenage daughter who is a makeup aficionado. I like the lengthening effect and the colour (black) but no matter what I do I end up with panda eyes after only a few hours of wear. For this I can't recommend for anyone where this has been an issue in the past.

my eyelashes are naturally stubbornly straight and even after using an eyelash curler, most mascaras don't hold the curl for more than like, ten minutes, EXCEPT roller lash. my eyelashes stay curled literally all day, i don't find that it smudges at all and the black is very black without it being too thick or goopy. i recommend this to everyone i know in real life.

Y'all know James Charles loves this and so do I. Does exactly what it says it does, and definitely gives a Roller-Lash effect. Love it. If you have stubborn straight lashes, take this one.

This is hands down my favourite mascara of all time! I have continued to repurchase it throughout the years and love the effect it has on my lashes. It never clumps, flakes or smudges and lengthens and curls the lashes in the most dreamy way possible! It is also easier to remove than most of the other Benefit mascaras.

I got this product as a sample and it was the best sample I have even gotten. I love this product so much it makes my lashes look so long and full and makes my eyes pop. get on it girls it is AMAZING!!!

I purchased this mascara as a mini, and I have never been happier with a mascara! I have started experimenting with a few of Benefit's products, and this little beauty is a fav. It glides on easily, curls magically and doesn't leave my lashes stuck together! The formula is smooth and it dries quite quickly - this is perfect for those with naturally long lashes, as it doesn't leave residue on the upper eye lid near brows - first ever for me!

Makes my lashes so inky black and stand out. And lengthens my lashes and holds their curl without making them look clumpy.

Absolutely love this product its amazing

The perfect, holy grail mascara. Is a staple in my make up bag. Coats your lashes perfectly without clumping or transferring.

Purchased this in the small travel sized version, at first, it was really good to apply - the brush complements the mascara well, and you're able to get all of your tiny lashes as well. However after 3-5 times use, I found that the mascara in the tube to become quite dry - and future uses became quite clumpy and not the same effect :/ Might have just been a bad batch, not sure!

Lovely mascara with lengthening effects and definitely adds a bit of curl if you remember to use your eyelash curler. HOWEVER my only con about this mascara is that if I don't use a curler and just apply the mascara on the eyelashes as is, at the end of the day the mascara ends up underneath my eyes and I look like I have bags. This may be because the formula isn't super dry? But then again, it doesn't cause much fall out which is a plus too. Great product, but I won't repurchase.

This is the best mascara ever!! Makes my eyelashes look so great

This product does amazing things. Helps me look more awake and attentive than I actually am. LOL! I love taking this item with me when I travel, and lately I notice I reach for this even when I'm home. The tiny size just makes it so much easier to apply. Will definitely purchase again.

i have the mini version of this mascara and i have been using it for a while now and still using it. it lasts very long time. also it is great for travelling and it gives volume as well as length to my lashes. totally recommended.

I HAVE VERY SHORT, STRAIGHT, FAIR LASHES AFTER THEY ALL FELL OUT AFTER CHEMO. I HAVE TRIED A MILLION DIFFERENT TYPES AND THIS IS DEFINITELY THE BEST. MY LASHES LIFTED WITHOUT THE USE OF AN EYELASH CURLER, DID NOT CLUMP AND DID NOT IRRITATE MY EYES. EASY TO APPLY AND REMOVE. I HAVE FINALLY FOUND THE ONE MASCARA THAT I LOVE. THANK YOU ADORE. ❤️

I received a rather decent sized sample of this mascara with another Benefit purchase ("They're Real" mascara - it's amazing).
Overall I didn't think that the Roller Lash was anything particularly great. I didn't notice any spectacular lashes from using it, but they did look nice and the formula didn't cause any irritation etc.
Keeping the sample in my "In Case of Emergencies" make-up bag, but won't purchase it.

It does what it says. Lifts and curls the lashes, I applied a couple of coats and was very impressed. It lasted all day.

I bought this after hearing rave reviews for the longest time but It irritates my eyes so much I can't use it. Application is great and it looks good but after 20 minutes I need to take it off :( I've had this with other benefit mascara's too so it's probably a brand formula thing.

Best mascara on the market. Leaves you with long, thick lashes without giving you panda eyes! Amazing.

I absolutely adore this mascara, it defines and lengthens without ever clumping, drying or flaking. The wand is perfect for curling and covering all of your lashes without getting product everywhere.

It stays beautiful all day and isn't difficult to remove, I couldn't recommend it enough. My all time favourite mascara!

I received a sample size of this when it first came out years ago and my partner totally fell in love with my lashes when I wore this. Even to this day, every other mascara I wear he compares to the roller lash and says how it doesn't live up to it. This mascara will give length like no other and will not clump or flake. I usually look for volume more than length, which is why I don't use it all the time, but this is a great product.

This is good but not my favorite. I always find myself wanting to rub my eyes after using this. But the look is good.

I was really surprised with the natural finish on this mascara. I hate clumpy and overdone looking lashes so this product is my go to for a subtle yet sexy look!

Love this mascara but I usually need to pair it with another benefit waterproof mascara over the top otherwise it gives me a bit of panda eye by the end of the day.

Pros: This gives amazing lash separation and length (not so much thickness but you get a little). It's a more natural everyday sort of look I think.

Cons: not waterproof, will smudge towards the end of the day. (if you need longevity or have oily eyelids like me just apply a waterproof mascara/clear coat over the top.)

Love it and will continue to repurchase.

I remember the ad for this compared it to rollers for your lashes, and the special brush kind of hooked the lashes and pulled them up.
I tgink it actually does do that. The brush really seems to pull the lashes up. My short straight lashes really look lifted and lengthened.
The brush is curved and comb like, it's really easy to get all the lashes and coats them evenly.
My lashes stay lifted all day. This doesn't smudge, smear or run all day.
This is a great mascara!

Love this product - I tried a sample size of this a few months back and found it worked amazingly well. I have naturally long lashes so some mascaras can feel quite heavy but this felt surprisingly light and I loved that it didn't clump or smudge.

This is my go to mascara. The roller lash has a perfect wand on it, making it easier to separate the lashes. This is my number 1 mascara. I highly recommend it.

this is an amazing product to add a bit of volume and to make your lashes look very long. it does not adds too much volume but it definitely makes your eyelashes look very long. i have gotten compliments after using this mascara. and a little goes long way.

i'm very picky with mascara. this mascara makes my lashes long & thick! not as thick and fluffy as BTS but! this mascara is so light you feel like you're not wearing mascara at all.. BTS feels very heavy and makes your eyes tired.
give this a try if you are wearing it all day. oily eyelids (and skin) and didn't smudge on me!
if its too natural looking for you just add one coat of something else on top and it'll make it look extra. i do that for nights out. i add bad gal bang on top and they go EXTRA wow!!

Super lengthening and curling!!

If you're after a higher end mascara for everyday I would reccomend the roller lash especially if you don't wear false lashes this one doesn't clump your lashes or make them look like spiders. Its a nice mascara and if you use it carefully it should last you a while although you should aim to use it up by 3-4 months for hygiene purposes. Definitely reccomend for those non-falsey days

I probably prefer this mascara to Bad Gal and They're Real. A nice lengthening and curling mascara with a simple and classic effect. Buildable.

I love using this mascara for my lower lashes it’s perfect and doesn’t smudge

You don’t need an eyelash curler as the wand works it’s curling magic for you! Also it’s really good for separating eyelashes and you can easily use the back of the wand for bottom lashes. Only downside is it does smudge easily so when using on bottom lashes it tends to end up under my eyes.

I bought this mascara in the mini and I do like the curling and definition it gives my lashes. It's not waterproof which isn't a huge deal but it takes forever to get rid of the panda eyes I'm left with, even after triple cleansing I still have to go to town with multiple wipes of makeup remover to get it off which is a huge nope from me and for the price I expect a better formula.

no clumps, it leaves the perfect amount of mascara on your lashes making them look very natural. perfect for daily use

It’s nice for a more natural look but I love bold lashes so will go back to ‘they're real’

I have been using this mascara for years now. I pair it with their volume enhancing one. Gives me super long and full looking lashes. The wand design just can’t be beaten. I think it’s good value for money.

Use this product if you want a classic natural look. It doesn't clump and lashes look long and sleek.

An amazing mascara! Love the volume and length it give my lashes. No massive clumps, no flaking.

I've been using this mascara for a couple of years. It creates great length and curls your lashes as well.

makes longer lashes, doesnt clump or smudge

I have very fine small eyelashes, when I use this mascara the length it gives is amazing. I have never had any problem with clumps either. The mascara is very easy to apply with the wand and easy to get to the root of your lash. I would and have definitely recommended to many people.

Very pretty mascara if you like curly natural lashes not too thick

I really like as an everyday mascara because it doesn't smudge like a lot of mascara do for me. However it doesn't make my lashes as fluffy and fanned out as I would like it to.

The best mascara ever!! Goes smoothly onto my lashes and doesn't go clumpy, i have gone through many of these!

For reference: I'm a big fan of natural looking mascaras. So nothing too clumpy or overly volumising. I love separated, long, curly lashes.

Roller Lash fulfills all my needs for a mascara and is absolutely gorgeous and stays put all day. However as it is more on the 'natural' side I'd say it's not for everyone as I know a lot of people love the big voluminous lash look. A little tip I have for keeping the mascara clump free and working at its best ability is to clean off the mascara wand every week or so which I find really helps it look natural and gorgeous.

My only complaint which isn't really a complaint which is why I won't dock a star, is that I wish it came in a waterproof form which would really boost its curl holding ability and give it more dependability in everyday wear. However this mascara is still great on its own!

Amazing mascara!!! my lashes have never looked prettier. Worth the price!

This is the product to use if you want a more natural look rather than heavy mascara / make up look. But I do find the price a bit too high for the quality.It doesn't smudge and dry up quickly which helps if you apply make up in a hurry like me. I also find it non irritating like some other well known brand. Perfect for me who wear contacts.

I heard great things about this, but honestly didn't love it. The brush is too plasticy and spiky for my liking and I am not such a fan of the way it makes my lashes look. Definitely not bad, but for the price I expect more!

Not really blown away by this mascara. It was ok, didn't clump too badly but no amazing results either. My lashes are short, so they definitely need to be curled before using this also, which kind of defeats the purpose.

If you want a Mascara from benefit, This would be the one I would go back to. It is much better that the they're real mascara, and does not clump. the applicator is sturdy and allows multiple applications without being clumpy , and if it does get a bit clumpy , I just wait for the mascara to dry a bit and use the applicator itself to seperate the lashes which works well.

I love the formula and mascara wand. It goes on easily without being chunky or clumping, and lasts for hours. Definitely a true black formula, and I’ve never had any issues with flaking or smudging.

Actually bought a mini for touch ups!

I have quite small eyes and lashes. The benefit rollerlash mascara brush is petite and narrow allowing me to coat all of my lashes well. I love the way I can apply once for long natural looking lashes or more times for thicker lashes. It stays put all day but it’s not waterproof so it’s not a nightmare to remove.

I bought this purely because Jeffree Star recommends this mascara above all overs. I have some pros and cons about it very, it is the perfect mascara for the lower lashline, as the wand is so fine it grabs each lash and makes your lower lashes looks plentiful, however this does nothing for the top lashes, it does not volumise or lengthen, It just adds mascara to your lashes, my top lashes don't look any thing special after using this,

I purchased this in the mini gives my eyelashes a beautiful lift and curl need to buy the full size

Does such a fantastic job and doesn't smudge or wear throughout the day. My lashes are full, plump and super long. Always get so many compliments wearing this mascara

works really well, not clumpy, smooth application. will buy again!

I seriously have the droopiest eyelashes. They point straight down and even when I curl them, five seconds later they've wilted again. This is the only mascara I've used that's managed to hold the curl. Possibly because it's a lighter formula. It doesn't make my eyelashes super thick, and instead makes them look lovely and long and natural. Doesn't clump at all.

I do like it, separates my lashes and makes them look so long. It's a HG for me

This mascara is perfect. Gives me length and volume with zero clumps.

I bought this mascara as I'd loved the Benefit They're Real mascara. While this one is good, i'm not sure if its worth the price as it lengthens but not to the point where I'm amazed by the results

I was so keen to try this after reading rave reviews but after an hour of lovely inky black, defined lashes my eyes started watering and I rubbed them in frustration... Then ended up with product all over my lids and under my eyes. A couple of hours later I came up in an angry red rash! I'm sure that I'm in a small percentage of people who've had this reaction but I can't recommend this to people with watery eyes or sensitive skin.

Provides volume and length with an easy to use wand. Can’t ask for more than that!

Good for a natural look and a glam look and doesn't weigh down my lashes and the brush makes it easy to avoid transferring mascara to the lid

This is the best mascara I have ever tried! It looks natural but also adds much needed volume and length. My only complaints are that at the end of the day the curl runs out and sometimes I get some mascara under my eyes. I wish it was waterproof but sadly it isn't. Keep in mind it does dry out within 3-4 months so replace often!

I love this so much!!! The plastic mascara wand seems to separate my lashes so well and somehow keeps them lengthened and curled all at the same time. Would recommend this!!!

I have straight eyelashes that won’t stay curled even with a heated eyelash curler. Not sure how benefit worked their magic here, but this mascara curls my straight eyelashes and makes them look amazing.

Great curl and lengthening action. My go-to formula!