Is Waterproof or Washable Mascara Better for Everyday Wear?

Waterproof vs plain old washable mascara: which is better for your lashes? Like so many things in the world of beauty, it depends on you. Here’s how to determine your best option.

Ultimately, the choice between waterproof and washable mascara comes down to personal preference and lifestyle. Whereas one formula might suit your bestie, it might not be the best pick for you. Here’s how to decide what’s right for you.

Is Waterproof or Washable Mascara Better for Everyday Wear?

Do You Work Out?

Think of your average day. How often do you wash your face? Do you work out daily? Are you a swimmer? Of course, in these situations, you’ve got two options. You can wear makeup that's easy to remove and reapply your makeup after your sweat session. Or you can opt for a durable, waterproof mascara.

If you swim, you need Clarins Truly Waterproof Mascara. This ultra-water-resistant mascara gives you 12-hour wear. Made from bitter orange tree wax and squalane, this formula protects against chlorine and leaves your lashes nourished and lush.

Do You Live in a Hot Climate?

If you live in a hot climate and sweat a lot, there are two good options. You can go for either a waterproof mascara or a clear mascara. Using a normal washable mascara is too risky if it’s hot enough for a makeup meltdown.

Is Waterproof or Washable Mascara Better for Everyday Wear?


Are Your Lashes Thick or Thin?

If your eyelashes are fragile or fine, it’s better to avoid waterproof mascara. There are some great hydrating formulas out there, but they can still be a bit much for extra-delicate lashes.

For a hydrating mascara that's gentle enough for even the most sensitive eyes, try Jane Iredale PureLash Lengthening Mascara. Available in Navy, Brown Black, and Jet Black, this mascara comes in the perfect shade to flatter anyone.

Can’t give up waterproof mascara? Use a mild but effective cleanser so you aren’t scrubbing at your eyes. We adore Estée Lauder Take It Away Makeup Remover Lotion.

Do You Wear Contacts?

If you wear contact lenses, it’s important to think about two things. First of all, you need a formula that works with sensitive eyes. Generally speaking, it’s better to get a mascara that specifically markets itself to contact-lens wearers.

Secondly, it’s generally best to go for a water-resistant mascara. There’s nothing more annoying that getting all your makeup done and then having to remove a lens for a quick smudge-removal.

If your eye makeup isn’t waterproof, it probably won’t withstand changing your contacts. On top of that, you want makeup that can stand up to eye drops when you need them.

One of the best mascara picks for contact-lens wearers is Laura Mercier Long Lash Mascara. Ophthalmologist-tested, this product is fibre-free and paraben-free.


Is Waterproof or Washable Mascara Better for Everyday Wear?

    Join Now >
    Filled with the usual things we know you'll love, and surprises you might not expect, it's real rewards, really simple.