definitely one of my all time fave foundation! i have oily-combination skin and this foundation lasts on my skin the whole day. i'm using NC15 but since mac has expanded the shade range even more, im so excited to be able to try maybe NC13 for a more accurate match. i love applying this foundation w/ beauty sponge for a flawless finish.
I've used this on nearly all my studio fix foundation bottles that I've gone through and while I do think it would be better if they just sold the SF foundation with the pump already on the bottle I think buying the pump is worth it. It disburses a manageable amount of product and you can alter your pressure on it to get little or more coming out.
This does a reasonable job of removing makeup, including waterproof mascara. However it does leave a sort of oily residue behind. I much prefer to use micellar water which is very effective and much cheaper.
I love this in shades Subculture and Boldly Bare. They are beautiful nude shades that work with just about every lipstick or gloss. I often use this pencil to fill in my whole lip and then top with clear lip gloss. Very flattering.