I have to say that I have tried sooooo many eyeliners with no success (I have oily eyelids). This is the best one I've tried so far but saying that I have to re-apply every two hours which I get sick of!
Received this as a sample and found it to be a soft easy to apply formula however, l did find it transferred. Throughout the day l found tiny black specs appeared around my eyes. The pigment was very good but it also made a mess when removing which took a while. Not sure if l would purchase the full size version.