Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye Mascara - Black

The best mascara I have ever used, it doesn't clump in my lashes, each lash gets volume and length and it looks like I am wearing fake eye lashes!!

Absolutely love love love this mascara, no clumping and definitely makes my lashes appear thicker and longer. I just wish it came in a waterproof option!

The last 6 months I have found some holy grails ..

Such a brilliant Mascara, it goes on smoothly (no clumps) and comes off easily. It's on the expensive side, but it's always worth paying for a product that works well.

I thought all mascaras were the some until I tried this one. It gives full fluffy lashes that are curled. It doesn’t clump at all but separates out the lashes and you look like you have had a lash lift.

Such a great mascara doesn’t go clumpy and doesn’t transfer

I love this mascara and have used it for special occasions over the years. It has a nice lightweight texture and doesn't go on too thick like some mascaras. The only problem i've had with it is that it's really hard to get off, and leaves a smudge around eyes.

I have very short eyelashes. Extensions are too expensive and I have tried most mascaras which some were okay and others.... not! I have tried ones that promise to lengthen and volumize.... broken promises.

The Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye Mascara has given me long lashes without clumping. I only have to put on a couple of coats and I am ready! I am very impressed with the product! Cleansing is very easy with little effort to remove the mascara.

I am very happy with it.

Absolutely love love love this mascara, no clumping and definitely makes my lashes appear thicker and longer. I just wish it came in a waterproof option!

I love bobbi brown products, and rarely buy one that disappoints, unfortunately this did. It flakes terribly for me through the day. I have long lashes with an eye profile that makes them my lashes hit my brow bone - not sure if this is the reason it flaked for me.

For what you get I feel this is quite pricey. It does add volume and length, and lasts all day but it didn’t wow me. I think there are cheaper options, but the formula isn’t too heavy and dries quite quickly ie it doesn’t leave your lashes wet so that you have to wait before blinking etc in order to not get mascara on your eye lids. Would probably buy again if it were a bit cheaper.

I have long fine eyelashes This mascara is great - makes my eyelashes look great and no clumping at all It’s pretty much the only beauty product that I actually always re-purchase

I have long but very straight lashes, I have tried many different mascaras and this is my current favourite. Like it says, it gives a smoky appearance without being smudgy and makes my lashes look dark and full. Definitely recommend!

The best mascara I have ever used, it doesn't clump in my lashes, each lash gets volume and length and it looks like I am wearing fake eye lashes!!

It’s a nice mascara and creates a nice natural look. Doesn’t smudge.

This is a decent mascara. It makes my lashes look longer.

I received a sample size in an order and it has quickly become my favorite. With one light coat it makes my lashes look so thick, luscious, long and curly. They have nailed the formula, as soon as my other mascaras on rotation get low I will be purchasing the full size asap!

I use this mascara as a second coat on my bottom lashes, but find it too 'crispy ' for my top ones.

I have fine short lashes and this mascara gives me similar lashes to when I have eyelash extensions!

This mascara is one of my beauty staples and it's always in my makeup bag! Makes my lashes look longer and fuller

This mascara gives me full and amplified lashes. Fantastic and long wearing

This mascara creates full and long lashes effortlessly without the clumping. I have gone through many tubes of this and will continue to re purchase. This mascara is also great for sensitive eyes and doesn’t cause irritation.

This mascara is the only mascara I currently trust in using. I have quite sparse eye lashes and this mascara really thickens them up. The only con is it can be quite gluggy when you have a brand new mascara, however I'm pretty sure this is the case with all mascaras. I have re-purchased this mascara over ten times by now! Love it!

Love this mascara! It has nothing to do with creating a smokey eye effect but as a mascara it does't clump or flake and stays on all day looking great. My lashes look long and voluminous.

BEST ever mascara. No glug. No smudge. Easy glide on. Perfect.

I base all my mascara reviews on whether they smudge or not as it's a huge issue for me. This is one of the few mascaras I've used that doesn't smudge. I usually use a tubing mascara but they don't always deliver the volume I'm looking for. This mascara gives volume and length, without the panda eyes.

This is my HG. No clumps or flakes, just long, black, voluminous lashes.
Pricy but I find it's worth it. Just be careful about sealing it properly as I've had 2 tubes loose the little keeper than scrapes off excess product where it has dried around the top.

A wonderful dark colour that stacks well, doesn’t clump and comes off cleanly. Did not irritate my eyes and didn’t smudge. Lengthened and added volume - there’s nothing this mascara can’t do! Love!

I normally get eyelash extensions because I have thin short lashes, I haven’t had them since I bought this mascara! It thickens and lengthens I love it! (First time I’ve ever reviewed a product I felt it was too good not to share!)

I received a free sample of this, I have sensitive eyes which can be very fussy with different mascaras. This didn’t irritate my eyes at all. No problems with smudging either. I wear this as an everyday mascara as it makes my lashes look long and separated but still natural.
It is very pricey for an everyday mascara and due to this I won’t purchase.

I love this mascara! It glides on so smoothly and isn't clumpy. The only negative i have is that it smudges a bit if you wear it for too long.

I'm torn on recommending this product because while I LOVE the mascara, I can't really justify the pricetag. It lengthens my lashes without clumping and I don't experience any flaking throughout the day (which is big for me as I touch my face/eyes often) but at $50 it's just a bit too dear for what it is.

This is a beautiful mascara. I was given this as a gift and I wouldn't buy this because it is expensive. It makes my lashes look longer and thicker.

I loved this mascara and was super sad when my tube ran out because unfortunately, I think it is probably a bit overpriced.
But if you are happy to spend the $50 then definitely go for it because it distributes the mascara nicely throughout the lashes.

I have long, thin eyelashes. I've tried a trillllllion different mascaras to try and get them clearly defined and relatively equally spaced. This mascara is one of the better ones I've tried. You do get definition and it does lengthen the lashes. However I am very picky about the brush head and this one does have a tendency to give me a little bit of clumpy-ness. Sooo, I might recommend it to someone with sparse, short eyelashes who needs some thickening and length, but it's not personally my go-to. Also it's pretty expensive for a small tube, it's not a regular sized tube of mascara.

This mascara really curled my lashes. It didn't smudge at all even with me accidentally rubbing me eyes (which happens a lot). I love the texture and how it enhances my not so present lashes. It is a but pricey though so I only buy it at duty free shops when I travel.

I have this mascara in a mini and have fair lashes. This mascara is great because it coats each lash without making them look clumpy. Will be purchasing this product again

Smokey Eye Mascara lives up to the name... will give you gorgeous, sexy eyelashes. Pigmentation is jet black. Provides beautiful volume, length and separation. It's an all-rounder mascara that ticks all the boxes. Extremely minimal smudging/flaking for me too. Almost unnoticeable. Definitely recommend it, though it is pricey, but eyes are the window to the soul ;)

Curls, separates and volumises, never clumpy and doesn't flake. Only down side is the price

This is a great BLACK mascara, it adds length and volume without clumping. It's my go to mascara for a night out because I know it won't budge, smudge or flake! I can always rely on this bad boy!

I'm really picky with mascara, i don't often find something that I will stick with but this is my favourite mascara ever. I'm up to my second tube and I can't go back. I wear it every day and it blends easily with false lashes too.

This mascara is my all time favourite mascara. I've never found a product that separates and volumises my lashes like this does. You can build it up without it ever going clumpy and it doesn't flake. It's super black too. Literally can't fault it. It is pricey but I will never go without it!

This is my go to mascara. As someone who already has good lashes, this product separates my lashes and evenly coats them making them look thicker and longer without the nasty clumps. It's doesn't smug off during the day either.