1. Home
  2. Brand
  3. jane iredale
  4. Jane Iredale Eye Pencil

Jane Iredale Eye Pencil
SIZE: 1.1g

4.3 of 45 reviews

4.3 of 45 reviews

$32.00

In Stock

In Stock

afterpay
4 installments of $5.63
paypal
zippay
Own it from $10/week
afterpay
4 installments of $5.63
paypal
zippay
Own it from $10/week

Most Helpful Positive

Terrific Taupe.

Patricia

I absolutely love this. I bought the taupe and it is beautiful. The colour is definite but soft, the pencil glides on without dragging and the colour lasts all ...

Is this for you?

Natural pigments give you long-lasting color that stays put, and these Pencils are creamy and easy to apply for a perfectly lined eye
  • Cruelty Free
  • Vegan
  • Paraben Free

What customers say

GREAT - 88% recommend

4.3
Read all reviews

Age:

  • Teens
  • 20s
  • 30s
  • 40s
  • 50+

Frequently bought with

Please wait while we find a match

Jane Iredale Eye Pencil Reviews

4.3 of 45 reviews

88% recommend this product

  1. 21

  2. 18

  3. 4

  4. 1

  5. 1

Most Helpful Criticism

Dry

Bekbek09

Too dried out at receiving the product
  1. Terrific Taupe.

    Patricia

    I absolutely love this. I bought the taupe and it is beautiful. The colour is definite but soft, the pencil glides on without dragging and the colour lasts all day. It is a beautiful, soft colour but with enough definition to be obvious. I prefer a natural look and this complements my eye makeup perfectly. I have super sensitive eyes but can wear this without any irritation.
  2. Creamy

    Harriet

    Super easy to apply with a soft formula. For a simple black kohl, it does a pretty solid job
  3. Beautiful everyday liner

    Chantelle

    Love this liner for everyday makeup. I purchased the black/brown shade and it looks beautiful.
  4. Super crumbly

    Soph

    This pencil liner was a no go for me. I couldn't even warm the eyeliner up on my hand because it would only crumble. I was very careful handling the pencil liner so perhaps it was dropped during delivery because it was extremely crumbly.
  5. Good

    LS

    Good pencil for waterline and to smoke out on the lash line.
  6. Dry

    Bekbek09

    Too dried out at receiving the product
  7. Eye pencil

    Nat

    I love the Jane Iredale brand - have lots of their makeup as it is non toxic and does not clog the skin I like this pencil - it does the job and does not irritate the eyes
  8. Good

    D

    just so soft does not hurt the eyes
  9. Good

    J

    creamy and smooth to apply
  10. Nice

    Ally

    Simple eye pencil, it does what it says. Pigment is nice and it stays on all day. Feels nice and soft to apply and has no irritating effect on my eyes.
  11. Beautiful taupe colour but it does not set

    Nsmn

    The colour is beautiful and the pencil is very creamy and glides easily. The issue is that it does not set after it is applied on skin, which means it would not be a suitable liner to draw sharp wings and it will smudge. I waited a good 10 minutes for it to set, but I cleaned it off skin easily only by rubbing.
  12. great formula

    Jessie

    just so soft does not hurt the eyes at all, and gives beautiful results. great eye pencil!
  13. Nice at first, but broke instantly when sharpened

    Arie Oldman

    This product was nice at first, creamy and smooth to apply, and stayed on for the whole day. However as soon as I tried to sharpen it, it chipped and broke. No matter how careful I was, it would break off. Perhaps it was bumped around during shipping?
  14. Difficult to apply but lovely colour

    Susan

    I bought this in "Taupe". The colour is exactly what I wanted for under my eyes, however I found the application difficult. It doesn't glide on easily for me as it does for other reviewers.
  15. Good

    Prabhjot

    Glides on easily and doesn't budge.
  16. So gentle on sensitive eyes

    HairFaceBody

    I have very sensitive eyes and can't use most eyeliners as they make my eyelids become itchy, red and swollen. The Jane Iredale pencil liner is my go-to for a soft look for everyday make up.

    I do wish Adore beauty would stock the Jane Iredale Mystikol eyeliner though - it's the only one which is acrylate-free, gives dramatic definition and doesn't irritate my eyes.
  17. Midnight blue shade is amazing

    Tash

    The Midnight blue shade is really special, I like to use it when I'm going for a catchy eye makeup look.
  18. Nice!

    Simmy

    Loved the application process it was just so smooth ! Great colour but I particularly loved that it was so easy to apply
  19. Nice eyeliner

    hl

    A pretty good eye pencil. Would recommend
  20. great eye pencil

    hol

    Love this eye pencil. It's very smooth and easy to blend. Would recommend
  21. Sensational.

    Lockhart

    This Taupe pencil is the best I have ever purchased. It is ACTUALLY taupe. Not brown, or dark brown. I have pale skin, so it is great. A really nice pastel brown tone. For anybody who states that brown liners are too harsh or stark for their eyes, use this pencil.
  22. Doesn't budge

    Dhanoa

    Super pigmented and doesn't budge all day. Would recommend.
  23. Nice

    O

    Glides on smoothly, super pigmented and creamy, lasts all day long and is easy to wash off!
  24. Color pay off might not work for medium to olive skin tones

    Swetha

    I bought the Taupe shade to give me that something something without being too obvious and the pencil is creamy enough as well. However it might work for someone who is of lighter skin tone as it doesn’t really show on my skin
  25. Great brown shade

    Swetha

    I use this on days when I don’t want to use a black liner which could be a little harsh and this color is perfect as it’s not too dark nor too light. It’s creamy enough to blend it out and smooth out the edges and stays put
  26. Lovely application

    Jo

    Glides on smoothly and is a lovely colour, this is one of the best taupe eye pencils I have tried
  27. Great

    as

    I really like how it goes on smoothly and doesn’t pull my skin. The brown color is a good shade. Not too dark or light
  28. great

    vicki

    i do love this product for the outside of my eyelid not inside where its wet as it smudged but its lovely and smooth going on :)
  29. Bomb!

    Shannon

    First time using this product after looking for a new eye liner. It’s a good product, creamy and easy to apply and remove. Not chalky. Does smudge a little if you don’t be careful but over all fantastic.
  30. Loving the color

    K

    love this eye pencil color!
  31. great!

    Lily

    This is so easy to use and looks great!
  32. Amazing!

    Simone

    The best I have used! Glides on so nicely.
  33. Best eyeliner ever!

    Ash

    I have been using this eyeliner for ten years and I won’t use any other pencil eyeliner now! I have tried others in the past but this is the best. It glides on effortlessly and doesn’t drag the skin at all. Great pigment too!
  34. Great value

    cat

    I love this eyeliner. It's super soft, so it doesn't pull the skin - but without being too smudgy. I get the midnight blue colour and it's beautiful. Very easy to apply.
  35. Nice

    Jess

    Nice eyeliner easy to apply and glides on smoothly however staying power is not great
  36. Good pencil

    Rachel

    I have this in white. I've always struggled to find a good white liner that works this is pretty good .. the best of a bunch I've tried so far
  37. Great for sensitive eyes

    Leonie

    This eyeliner is lovely to use. I have super sensitive eyes and this product does not irritate it. The formula is nice and creamy but does not smudge easily unless you rub your eyes. Really recommend it for an everyday eyeliner
  38. soft head, really easy to apply!

    jing

    I was in doubt to be honest when getting this eye pensil. eye pensils are so different.... you never know what you are getting online. but Jane Iredale really suprised me, really easy to apply and do not go messy on the eyes too. I love it. and will definitely buy it again.
  39. Creamy pencil

    Alex

    The pencil is in a nice creamy form, that glides really gently onto your eye, no tugging at your eyelids. It's really easy to use, making a nice smokey eyeliner effect and the stay effect is average. This is definitely a light creamy coloured pencil, it is not very pigmented.
  40. Perfectly smooth!

    Evangeline

    This is the smoothest eyeliner I've found so far! It applies gently to my eyes without 'tugging' at the skin. I like a neat line that I can leave as is or smudge slightly and this does the job perfectly. It doesn't rub off or make a mess after a few hours which is great too! I bought this in Black! Love it!
  41. Smooth and easy to use

    Abby

    This product is so easy to use and creates the perfect smoky eye. Works great as a base for dark shadow or metallic effect shadow. Also works great alone.
    I love to apply it along my lash line (top and bottom) and then smoke it out with my finger or a pencil brush (the sigma pencil brush works well for this) for a sultry Parisian lined eye. It does tend to smudge or move throughout the day/n...
    Read More
  42. Smooth but does smudge if rubbed

    mrslandl

    I'm do rub my eyes and these do smudge. But it applies on so smoothly and the colour is nice and dark so you don't have to go over your eyelids several times.
  43. Great with sensitive eyes

    Joanne

    I love these pencils! My eyes are sensitive to so much makeup, but not to these. They go on easily, can be blended nicely and stay put.
  44. Very good product

    Sally

    Jane Iredale Eye Pencil is soft and has just the shade I was after. This eye pencil is easy to apply, and does not run, even at the end of the day.
  45. Excellent product

    Lorraine

    Have been using Jane Iredale products for approx 12 months and have always found it to be a great product and this eye pencil is no different would definitely keep on using, great product.
  46. Review & Earn
Recommended for you

Find more of...

Related Searches

Subscribe for beauty sales, free goodies, advice and SO much more!