1. Home
  2. Brand
  3. Benefit Cosmetics
  4. Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

4.6 of 421 reviews

4.6 of 421 reviews

$48.00

In Stock

In Stock

afterpay
4 installments of $12.00
paypal
zippay
Own it from $10/week
afterpay
4 installments of $12.00
paypal
zippay
Own it from $10/week

Most Helpful Positive

Probably the only i would ever use

Mani

This is probably the only brow product i would ever use. I love how easily it glides and gives the most natural look

Is this for you?

Oh my WOW…precise & defined brows! Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil is the ultimate brow defining pencil. The ultra-fine tip draws incredibly natural-looking hair-like strokes while the textured, custom-control grip gives extra control.

What customers say

SUPERIOR - 94% recommend

4.6
Read all reviews

Frequently bought with

Please wait while we find a match

Questions & Answers

(1 Question)

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Get an expert to answer your question about this product!

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil Reviews

4.6 of 421 reviews

94% recommend this product

  1. 284

  2. 113

  3. 19

  4. 4

  5. 1

Most Helpful Criticism

Good but Ridiculously Overpriced

Sayera

Great range of shades and a fine tip that's good for drawing on individual hairs, however definitely not even close to being worth the price. I went through thi...
  1. Probably the only i would ever use

    Mani

    This is probably the only brow product i would ever use. I love how easily it glides and gives the most natural look
  2. I hate how much I LOVE it

    Soph

    I recently got a little sample of this and my god, doesn't compare to any other brow pencil I've tried. I'm not sure what it is about it, gives the perfect amount of pigment and the perfect stroke. The only thing that really lets it down is how much money it is. If you have the money to spend, buy this!
  3. Overpriced

    Mia

    This item has such little product it finished so quickly. It’s great if you’re gonna use it sparingly but otherwise is overpriced.
  4. go-to brow pencil

    Alice

    My go-to and holy grail brow pencil easy to use and looks natural very buildable as well. only downside is I find it breaks/snaps easily and therefore often doesnt last long
  5. Great

    PK

    Great brow pencil, very fine tip and doesn't smudge.
  6. Great! But overpriced

    Katina

    I’ve been using this for years and love the colour match to my eyebrows. My only problem is the price tag - it’s overpriced! Other than that, it’s a solid eyebrow pencil option. I also use it to draw on freckles on my nose.
  7. Perfect for daily use

    AimeeR

    This was recommended by my brow artist as touch ups in between appointments. I was previously a user of brow gel rather than a pencil - and I'm so glad I have given this a go. The fine pencil allows for accuracy without being over-the-top, coupled with the spooly to blend means my brows are on-point EVERY DAY.
  8. Perfect

    Brow pencil

    This brow pencil is the best product for eyebrows I’ve tried many other brands but this is the best one
  9. brows for days

    varsh

    Having tried quite a few brow products, I am a big big fan of this benefit product. This has easily been the one brow product I keep purchasing. Easy to use, stays on and looks natural. I've found this great for a beginner like me
  10. foolproof product

    mik

    super buildable, perfect for natural or heavy glam looks
  11. Benefit Precisely Eyebrow Pencil

    Janetb

    I don’t know what’s happened with this product , used it for years and then suddenly after purchasing a number of units over the recent past, the pencil mechanism is faulty and they are scrimping on how much pencil is actually supplied!!! It’s costly & faulty! Totally over it! Don’t buy!!!
  12. Easy

    MzJay28

    Easy to use. Thin hair like strokes, lasts all day and has a spoolie at the end. Quick application.
  13. Great

    Singh

    Great brow product, easy to use and doesn't budge.
  14. The best one out there

    Charlotte

    I love this product, it so easy to use and leaves my eyebrows looking full and natural. It's a bit pricey and I tend to go through it fast as I use daily. I've tried some other cheaper varieties, but nothing compares to the quality of this one. Probably worth the investment here.
  15. Great control

    Mali

    I use 2.5 which is a light blind with no red undertone. You can do very precised lines with it. I really like it. I wish they has changable infills so you Diane need to throw away so much packaging.
  16. won't use anything else

    V

    Love this! Love how many shades it comes in, love how easy it is to use. Love how natural it looks, love how the tip doesn't require sharpening and stays precise!
  17. BEST. BROW. PENCIL. EVER.

    Nim

    Scrap all the other brow products you have, and just get this. trust me it's the most natural looking, fine tip, and just perfect pencil out there to get the most natural yet full looking brows. I'm never looking back!!
  18. Got brow now

    Liz

    I am always looking for brow products since my brows are very sparse due to laser job gone wrong and this product does not disappoint and have staying power.
  19. Perfect brows

    Ailish

    Favourite brow product. Really easy to fill in brows, without them looking over-filled or fake.
  20. favourite eyebrow pencil

    claire

    just wish it was less overpriced
  21. Pretty good!

    M

    Benefit was one of the only brands that had a decent colour match for my brows. This pencil is easy to use and goes on well, able to use it lightly for shading which is good. Could be a bit thinner in my opinion to really get those hair like strokes
  22. Perfect brow

    Maddi

    if you want perfect clean brows get this pencil
  23. The Only Brow Product I'll Use

    Rach

    This brow pencil is fantastic. Skinny nib for precise application, stays put all day and the key that makes this so good is the shade. The shades available are wide and varied - I use 3.5 which has a great slightly greyish undertone which looks soft, natural and beautiful when applied, no harsh brows here. Will repurchase time and again.
  24. a bit pricey but such a great product

    hiya

    the formula is so smooth, and i love how the brow pencil is so thin so that application is so effortless
  25. okay brow pencil

    z

    i like this, but i'm not sure it is worth the price
  26. i mean it works...

    m

    this product works, and honestly there's no complaints, but there is honestly nothing special about it that justifies the price
  27. Best brow pencil

    Nadine

    Love this product! Have been using it for years now! Great price and colours! Would recommend
  28. So thin and precise.

    :)

    These mimic real eyebrow hairs.
  29. Bestest brow product on the market

    Hu

    As expected this product is amazing for my brows. The pencil is so thin and precise. And its so easy to use and blend. Does the work for me. Worth the money.
  30. Real

    U

    ultra-fine tip draws incredibly natural-looking hair-like
  31. Natural defined brows but runs out quickly

    AllyP

    This is fantastic and allowing you to create natural and full looking brows but it runs out really quickly for the price, maybe a month of daily use
  32. My go to

    Iss

    beautiful, natural brow look
  33. Nice

    Winny

    creamy, pigmented micro brow pencil
  34. Nice

    I

    precise & defined brows
  35. Noce

    U

    ultimate brow defining pencil
  36. Ez

    C

    Easy to use My goto
  37. Brows feeling great

    Danielle

    I like this brow pencil and I find it helps me fill in my brows and use the brush to blend it through well
  38. Great

    B

    full, natural-looking brows effortlessly
  39. Nice

    S

    that's good for drawing on individual hairs
  40. Nice

    S

    Great range of shades
  41. Nice

    S

    Great range of shades
  42. Good

    A

    full, natural-looking brows
  43. Nice

    L

    Great range of shades and a fine tip that's good for drawing on individual hairs
  44. Nice

    Ns

    Great range of shades
  45. Recommend

    Ori

    full, natural-looking brows effortlessly in no time flat
  46. Everyday use

    Ber

    I use this brow pencil everyday along with the brow gel, they work amazingly in making my eyebrow look fuller. Easy to use too.
  47. Nice

    Na

    Great range of shades and a fine tip that's good for drawing on individual hairs
  48. Great

    O

    Really great for being able to create hair-like strokes
  49. Prefer

    Will

    Really great for being able to create hair-like strokes
  50. Perfect brows

    Ailish

    Really great for being able to create hair-like strokes and create a natural, full looking brow.
  51. Precise

    EP

    Really good brow pencil, it worths the money. It is precise, glides easily but does not smudge and stays all day.
  52. Fantastic

    Qiqi

    It's natural and long lasting. Good range of colour. Definitely will repurchase.
  53. Fun Packaging

    Bea

    The packaging was what drew me to this product, it looks so fancy for a brow pencil. The formula also is pretty gret too.
  54. Go to

    Jaylees

    I've been using this for years! Honestly such a go to. It's really fine and precise so you can shape your brows really well. It's buildable too so you can go for whatever look.
  55. Good product

    A

    Easy to use and natural looking. Wish it had longer staying power though. Smudges off by end of day
  56. Best Brow Product

    Thea

    Very easy to use and create a natural brow look Easy to build up and adjust
  57. go-to brow pencil

    an

    have been using this brow pencil everyday and has never failed to disappoint! glides onto the skin nicely and the attached brush comes in handy. only downside is the price
  58. Makes brow filling that much easier

    Linda M

    Very happy with this and my favourite feature is the additional brush. I purchased the number 2 shade but I think I could also use number 3. I use it to fill in the top arch section of the brow and I like the natural look it gives. Will be purchasing again for sure!
  59. Great for blonder eyebrows

    Brooke

    I have a hard time finding eyebrow pencils that don't look orange. The ash blonde is perfect for me--matches my eyebrows exactly, even though I have brown hair. The fine pencil is great and the packaging holds up better than another brand in a similar price range. Will repurchase for sure.
  60. Love it !

    Crystal

    Super easy to use expecally on the go ! Creamy and precise
  61. Really simple to use

    Vicvic

    This was my first brow pencil, and was really easy to apply for a natural look.
  62. Great product

    Amy

    Great product. Easy to use. Wish it was waterproof.
  63. Good but Ridiculously Overpriced

    Sayera

    Great range of shades and a fine tip that's good for drawing on individual hairs, however definitely not even close to being worth the price. I went through this super fast and decided to get a drugstore alternative instead of repurchasing and am just as happy.
  64. Best of the Best

    KelliM

    Benefit always delivers with brow & lash products. This pencil is fine & delivers a super tidy look that look like real hair strokes. Great for defining the top line of the brow too
  65. Lasts a long time

    Kendall

    LOVE this eyebrow pencil. Usually I’d go for a savey eye pencil but this changed my mind. I love that it is cool in colour so it blends well into my natural colour and doesn’t throw red like a lot do. It’s got a nice creamy texture and lasts all day
  66. love it

    Brittany

    fantastic brow pencil. Really thin so the lines can be precise but i've never had one snap on me. I've had two of these pencils now, and both have been excellent. i love a natural yet defined brow and this gives me the results with minimal effort.
  67. Favourite brow pencil

    Chez

    I used benefits goof proof for years but bought this by accident from the benefit store. Tried it and loved it. It’s so nice and feel lighter compared to goof proof. And the colour is great and long lasting. The pencil nib is a bit thin, so be gentle so it doesn’t snap. But definitely repurchasing
  68. Great application

    Anne

    The shape of the tip allows me to get a more precise application, and the brush on the opposite end allows me to diffuse the colour so it looks more natural. I do try to be careful with it though since the pencil is quite thin and feels a bit delicate.
  69. My go to brow product

    Hayley

    The pencil is super thin which makes it easy to apply.
    The product is really easy to work with and leaves your eyebrows looking natural.
    The product does use up pretty quickly for the price so I always buy a couple at a time.
  70. Pretty good

    Jay

    I was exploring alternatives to the usual shu uemura hard formula. This was pretty good - easy to control and there's a good range of colour options.
    Still prefer the shu uemura one, as it seems to last longer and I personally find that it looks more natural, but this one was pretty good!
  71. Awesome

    Louise

    This is a fantastic pencil. Effective, super natural and easy to use.
    I use it with the benefit brow gel.
  72. Love

    Jess

    This product is lovely! Easy to use with precise application. I love how thin the tip is which means precise lines every time, however its so thin that you only get minimal product and it a little expensive for the price. Would still probably repurchase though because of all the great brow days ive been having!
  73. Good but snaps A LOT

    Charlotte

    I loved this brow pencil/crayon. The thinness is great for making small strokes in the brow and makes them super natural looking. It's a good texture etc BUT it snaps ALL THE TIME! It got to the point where it was snapping every time I used it. I feel like you only get to use half of the product by the time you get to the bottom.
  74. Very precise as named

    Tennille

    This pencil is goof proof as it has an ultra fine tip that you use to gradually build your brow
    colour up. Only thing is I have a different brow product that I prefer the colour of. If I was
    not using that this pencil would be my next option
  75. best eye brow pencil

    keke

    The best eye brow pencil I found so far. A little bit expensive but have not found an alternative yet
  76. precise!!! looks natural

    keke

    My go-to brow pencil. Each one lasts couple of months. A little bit expensive though
  77. AMAZING

    A

    Love it, this product is absolutely perfect if you have fine, thinner brows :)
  78. favourite eyebrow pencil

    bec231

    I'm really blonde and I finally found a food colour for my eyebrows, love this!
  79. Brow beauty

    Stella

    Fills in your brow gaps! Perfect size too.
  80. Great brow product!

    Caity

    Makes my eyebrows look AMAZING!
  81. Best brow product I have tried

    Stella

    This is the most natural brown product I have tried. Fills in the gaps and a good range of shades to choose from.
  82. The best!

    Sarah

    Lives up to its expectation! Beautiful texture, smooth, great colour. Don't need to apply much pressure. Love!
  83. Amazing!!

    J

    So simple, but makes such a difference :)
  84. Natural

    Mag

    Perfect for a discreet and delicate makeup brows. It makes fine lines, is not greasy and doesn’t pill. The eyebrow remains natural. On the other hand, be careful not to break the pencil mine, it is so fine that it is fragile... it would be a shame...given the price
  85. great eye brow pencil

    ndavey

    this is a great eyebrow pencil it is the perfect amount of smooth and blendable and gives and exact line, very impressed and would buy again
  86. My favourite

    Sophie

    I have tried other brow pencils but this is my favourite by far. I have ombre brows from having them microbladed.
    This helps to deepen and give a full affect to my brows.
    I love this product so much. I have just ordered another.
    Great with a spooli on the end and finish with eyebrow gel and it looks great.Love it!!!
  87. Works wonders

    Clau

    I use this pencil every day and it's pretty good, however it annoys me so much waste of plastic! Every one of these have a brush but when I buy the one without the brush comes like 50% less pencil.... Why? I just want the same amount of pencil but I have so many brushes that is not necessary!
    The price is a bit too much as well, it could be less without having the brush.
  88. The best brow product

    Tam

    I’ve been buying this pencil for about 5 years. Previously I used a powder but moved away from that cause it was easy to overdo it and have a bad brow day with obviously filled in brows. This product just gets such a natural finish. I think sometimes people don’t know I even have product in - sometimes people compliment me on my ‘natural brows’ but it’s all cause of this pencil that somehow just l...
    Read More
  89. shade 6

    sha

    shade 6 is the perfect cool toned black brown shade for those with black hair. so many brands have really warm toned pencils but this is such a perfect shade. the tip is super precise for creating hair like strokes
  90. Amazing

    Prabhjot

    Natural looking, doesn't smudge, lasts all day even through sweaty brow days. I love the packaging too.
  91. Love this

    Bec

    Love this brow pencil, lasts so long as well so well worth the money. Easy to use and the brush end blends in the pencil well. I have dark brown hair And like my brows fairly dark. I use the number 4 shade.
  92. you'll never use anything else

    Molly

    So easy to use and gives a natural look to eyebrows. I never buy anything else now and the colour range means you'll find your perfect match. Doesn't smudge, stays put all day
  93. best brow pencil

    ya

    this is my holy grail brow pencil. it's so easy to shape your brows and still have it look natural because of the super fine and precise tip
  94. The perfect brow pencil!!!!!

    J

    I love this thing - I have really thin brows and it lets my fill them in as much as I want without looking freakily fake. You can pencil your brows in really precisely or feather it and blur (with the spoolie) so that you get a more natural look. Definitely give it a go!! :))
  95. Great for the lazy and time-poor

    Emily

    As I've said in some of my other reviews, I don't often wear makeup at all as my work hours and long and I really don't care!. My go-to look is Clarins Flash Beauty balm, brows, mascara and some tinted lip balm (Bobbi Brown). This is my favourite brow pencil as, despite not having a spoolie or brush for a quick sculpt, it has good staying power and blends well. I simply use a cheap old brow brush,...
    Read More
  96. Great eyebrow pencil

    Cindy C

    This is a great eyebrow pencil, love the shape of the pencil and the colour pay off. Makes it super easy for me to do my brows in the morning. The colour holds pretty well throughout the day, even with my oily skin. Took 1 star off because of the price!
  97. Took time to like

    Sez

    At first use it had a grey film over the pencil. It was only once I warmed it up and rubbed it on the back of my hand for a while that the film wore away and the pigment came through. I was scared to brake it while trying to wear away the film. After that it was good to go.
  98. naturally bulks up your brown

    stacey

    makes fine hairs look thick and can be used to give an amazing shape
  99. Neat and precise

    Trin

    This is a great eyebrow pencil as it applies well and is well suited to my shade however i have found that the stick is slightly fragile.
  100. Best eyebrow pencil

    Katie

    I've been on a quest for the best eyebrow products over the last year and I keep coming back to this brow pencil paired with the Gimme Brow. The product is really easy to use, as it has a smooth consistency. The only issue I had is that it seemed to run out quite fast but at this price, I'm happy to buy it again when it runs out.
  101. Review & Earn
Recommended for you

Find more of...

Related Searches

Subscribe for beauty sales, free goodies, advice and SO much more!